1. The Return

2. A Church Divided

3. Love Your Enemies

The elders ask Levi and Merlin to join forces; Levi mobilizes the Amish to have their first vote; Merlin and Mary go after one of Doug's men.

4. Forbidden Knowledge

5. Merlin's Judas

6. False Prophets

Levi and the Mennonites battle for the book of Menno; the Constable investigates Levi further; Merlin and Mary confront uncomfortable truths.

7. Day of Reckoning

Susanna visits Levi unexpectedly; Doug orders Alan and Caleb to exact revenge.

8. The End Is Near